List vs IEnumerable vs IQueryable vs ICollection vs IDictionary

迷南。 2022-06-16 02:36 290阅读 0赞

原文：[http://www.codeproject.com/Articles/832189/List-vs-IEnumerable-vs-IQueryable-vs-ICollection-v][http_www.codeproject.com_Articles_832189_List-vs-IEnumerable-vs-IQueryable-vs-ICollection-v]

*  [IList vs IEnumerable vs IQueryable vs ICollection vs IDictionary][]
 *  [IList vs IEnumerable vs IQueryable vs ICollection vs IDictionary - 494.3 KB][]

![CompleteCollectionComparison.jpg][]

## Collection ##

Set or group of records which makes one meaningful unit: In fetch and modification progress we need appropriate [Container][] to store them temporary in it. Appropriate container depends on: 1. Our action which we want to do on data ( just read, do modification such as insert, delete, etc ) 2. Number of records which should be transfer

![1.jpg][]

## Array ##

1. Fixed Length -> difficult to change the nember of count 2. Type Safe -> you determin its type at coding process (it has better performance due to do not consume time at run time to spesific type countainer ) 3. Use “for” keyword to fill and iterate through array Array is faster than Arraylist because it is fixed sized and srong type, so it needs less memory due to its data type and dimenssion is determined

![2.jpg][]

![minus.gif][]  Collapse  |  [Copy Code][]

//It is obvious that strArray is         //1. string --> Strongly Type         //2. Sized=10 --> Fixed Size 
            string[] strArray = new string[10];
    
            for (int i = 0; i < 10; i++)
            {
                if (strArray[i]==null)
                {
                    strArray[i] = (i+1).ToString();
                }
            }
    
            this.ListBoxArray.DataSource = null;
            this.ListBoxArray.Items.Clear();
    
            this.ListBoxArray.DataSource = strArray;
            this.ListBoxArray.DataBind();

## ArrayList ##

1. It does not have spesific length -> It is possible to grow data , it is good feature because of at the first we are not likely to sure about length of collection 2. Arraylist does not have any spesific type and it will be determined at run time, its adbantage is when you are not sure about type of data untill in run time user detemines it, and its disadvantage is to reduce performance by consuming time , so use it just when you need it it is like var or object 3. Use “foreach” keyword for iterate through it

![3.jpg][]

![minus.gif][]  Collapse  |  [Copy Code][]

public class Product
        {
            public Product()
            {
            
            }
            public Product(string Code, string Name)
            {
                _Code = Code;
                _Name = Name;
            }
    
                        public string _Code {get; set;}
                public string _Name { get; set; }
        }

ArrayList can accept string , integer and decimal at the same time

![minus.gif][]  Collapse  |  [Copy Code][]

//It is NOT obvious that strArrayList is 1. string? int? object? decimal? --> NOT Strongly Type         // 2. Sized=10? 20? 100? -->NOT Fixed Size         // Namespace: System.Collections 
            System.Collections.ArrayList strArrayList = new System.Collections.ArrayList();
            //System.Linq.IQueryable type of data is not specific runtime defered support         strArrayList.Add("Mahsa");  // "Mahsa": is string         strArrayList.Add(1);        // 1 : is integer         strArrayList.Add(0.89);     // 0.89: is decimal 
            this.ListBoxArrayList.DataSource = null;
            this.ListBoxArrayList.Items.Clear();
            this.ListBoxArrayList.DataSource = strArrayList;
            this.ListBoxArrayList.DataBind();
    
            System.Text.StringBuilder str= new System.Text.StringBuilder();
    
            foreach (var item in strArrayList)
            {
                str.Append(" , "+item);
            }
            this.lblArrayList.Text = str.ToString();
            
            //Below is old way to fill obj from product , in Arraylist you need to create more than one instance        // Product objProduct = new Product();        // objProduct.Code = "1001";        // objProduct.Name = "Chair"; 
            //It is NOT obvious that strArrayList is         //1. string? int? object? decimal? OR OBJECT?? --> NOT Strongly Type         //2. Sized=10? 20? 100? -->NOT Fixed Size         // Namespace: System.Collections 
            System.Collections.ArrayList objArrayList = new System.Collections.ArrayList();
    
            objArrayList.Add(new Product("1001", "Chair"));
            objArrayList.Add(new Product("1002", "Sofa"));
            objArrayList.Add(new Product("1003", "Carpet"));
    
            this.DropDownListArrayListObject.DataSource = null;
            this.DropDownListArrayListObject.Items.Clear();
            this.DropDownListArrayListObject.DataSource = objArrayList;
    
            //* Finding among Object of Array List is difficult , you have to find your specific item by index         Product objTemp = (Product)objArrayList[0];
            objArrayList.Remove(objTemp);
            //*         this.DropDownListArrayListObject.DataTextField = "_Name";
            this.DropDownListArrayListObject.DataValueField = "_Code";
            this.DropDownListArrayListObject.DataBind();
            this.GridViewArrayListObject.DataSource = objArrayList;
            this.GridViewArrayListObject.DataBind();

## HashTable ##

![4.jpg][]

![minus.gif][]  Collapse  |  [Copy Code][]

//It is NOT obvious that strArrayList is         //1. string? int? object? decimal? OR OBJECT?? --> NOT Strongly Type         //2. Sized=10? 20? 100? -->NOT Fixed Size         // Namespace: System.Collections         //Hashtable solve the problem in Arraylist when we are looking for specific item         //Hashtable dedicate a key for each item, then finding item is easier and faster 
             System.Collections.Hashtable objHashTable = new System.Collections.Hashtable();
           
             objHashTable.Add("1001","Chair");
             objHashTable.Add("1002", "Sofa");
             objHashTable.Add("1003", "Carpet");
    
         
            this.DropDownListHashTable.DataSource = null;
            this.DropDownListHashTable.Items.Clear();
            this.DropDownListHashTable.DataSource = objHashTable;
            //* finding item is easier you just need to point to it by call its key         objHashTable.Remove("1002");
            //*         this.DropDownListHashTable.DataTextField = "Value";
            this.DropDownListHashTable.DataValueField = "Key";
            this.DropDownListHashTable.DataBind();

## Stack ##

![5.jpg][]

#### Stack - Push ####

![minus.gif][]  Collapse  |  [Copy Code][]

//Stack is LIFO: Last in First Out         System.Collections.Stack objStackPush = new System.Collections.Stack();
    
            //By Push method you can insert item at the top of the stack         objStackPush.Push("Mahsa");
            objStackPush.Push("Hassankashi");
            this.lblPop.Text = "";
            this.ListBoxStack.DataSource = objStackPush.ToArray();
            this.ListBoxStack.DataBind();

#### Stack - Pop ####

![minus.gif][]  Collapse  |  [Copy Code][]

System.Collections.Stack objStackPop = new System.Collections.Stack();
    
            objStackPop.Push("Mahsa");
            objStackPop.Push("Hassankashi");
    
            //By Pop method you can remove item from the top of the stack --> Last in First in         this.lblPop.Text = objStackPop.Pop().ToString();
    
            this.ListBoxStack.DataSource = objStackPop.ToArray();
            this.ListBoxStack.DataBind();

## Queue ##

![6.jpg][]

#### Queue - Enqueue ####

![minus.gif][]  Collapse  |  [Copy Code][]

//Queue is FIFO: First in First Out         System.Collections.Queue objQueue = new System.Collections.Queue();
    
            //By Enqueue method you can insert item at the END of the Queue         objQueue.Enqueue("Mahsa");
            objQueue.Enqueue("Hassankashi");
            objQueue.Enqueue("Cosmic");
            objQueue.Enqueue("Verse");
    
            this.lblQueue.Text = "";
            this.ListBoxQueue.DataSource = objQueue.ToArray();
            this.ListBoxQueue.DataBind();

#### Queue - Dequeue ####

![minus.gif][]  Collapse  |  [Copy Code][]

System.Collections.Queue objQueue = new System.Collections.Queue();
    
            objQueue.Enqueue("Mahsa");
            objQueue.Enqueue("Hassankashi");
            objQueue.Enqueue("Cosmic");
            objQueue.Enqueue("Verse");
    
            //By Dequeue method you can remove item from the BEGINING of the Queue --> First in First out FIFO         this.lblQueue.Text=objQueue.Dequeue().ToString();
           
            this.ListBoxQueue.DataSource = objQueue.ToArray();
            this.ListBoxQueue.DataBind();

## List ##

Why we needList? 1. List does not have spesific length à It is possible to have data without knowing its size , it is good feature because of at the first we are not likely to sure about length of collection. 2. List has Spesific type so it is strong type, therfore it has better perfomance and high speed in comparison with ArrayList and reduce unwanted error in compile time. 3. Use “foreach” keyword for iterate through it.

![7.jpg][]

![minus.gif][]  Collapse  |  [Copy Code][]

//Like Array is Strong Type
            //Like ArrayList with No Dimension
    
            System.Collections.Generic.List<string> strList = new List<string>();
    
    
            strList.Add("Mahsa");
            strList.Add("Hassankashi");
            strList.Add("Cosmic");
            strList.Add("Verse");
           
            this.ListBoxListGeneric.DataSource = strList;
            this.ListBoxListGeneric.DataBind();
    
            System.Text.StringBuilder str = new System.Text.StringBuilder();
    
            foreach (var item in strList)
            {
                str.Append(" , " + item);
            }
            this.lblList.Text = str.ToString();

## IList ##

Why we need IList? Ilist is an interface of list (does everything that List does) and to observe polymorphism in order to decouple and control on add or remove method that implement on the client side, everything else are similar to List. Whenever we want to change on some operation “IList” allow us to do that easily with at least changing in the whole of codes. Ilist can not be instantiate from Ilist , so it should be instantiate from List

![minus.gif][]  Collapse  |  [Copy Code][]

System.Collections.Generic.IList<string> strIList = new List<string>();

### Difference between Abstract and Interface ###

1.Abstract inherit from just one class but Interface implements from one or more interfaces 2.Abstract can have non concrete method (expand method) but you have to define just signature inside interface 3.Inside Abstract class you can define variable and value but you are not allowed to define variable inside interface 4.An abstract class can have constructor but inside interface you are not allowed to define constructor 5.You can write scope for member of interface, red ones donot allow but blue one allow Ilist is an interface and as I mentioned that how a class cannot be driven from two class it just can be driven from only one class, so whenever you want to drive from two class it is not possible to inherit from two abstract class but it is possible to drive from one class and another one Ilist as interface Later in future you decide add some features on your class and inherit it from another class So because of this reason we always prefer to use interface of collection so that if you want to change your code and enhance its abilities it is possible to grow it On the otherhand interface keeps your program extensible and Decouple: The classes are independent from each other error, exeption and failur will happen rarly in future changing code Polymorphism: When you are using interface you absolutly observe and do polymorphism and oop it means encapsulate your designer Interface means a point or a node to join two part to eachother it means making low dependency from two part and make a joint section to make felxible chang in future

![minus.gif][]  Collapse  |  [Copy Code][]

//Ilist can not be instantiate from Ilist , so it should be instantiate from List         System.Collections.Generic.IList<string> strIList = new List<string>();
    
            strIList.Add("Mahsa");
            strIList.Add("Hassankashi");
            strIList.Add("Cosmic");
            strIList.Add("Verse");
    
            
            this.ListBoxListGeneric.DataSource = strIList;
            this.ListBoxListGeneric.DataBind();
    
            System.Text.StringBuilder str = new System.Text.StringBuilder();
    
            foreach (var item in strIList)
            {
                str.Append(" , " + item);
            }
            this.lblList.Text = str.ToString();

IList is similar to List but with this difference that we prefer to use INTERFACE instead of abstract in programming because future changing is easy

## IEnumerable ##

IEnumerable is suitable just for iterate through collection and you can not modify (Add or Remove) it IEnumerable bring ALL data from server to client then filter them, assume that you have a lot of records so IEnumerable puts overhead on your memory

![8.jpg][]

![minus.gif][]  Collapse  |  [Copy Code][]

//IEnumerable can not be instantiate from Enumerable , so it should be instantiate from List         System.Collections.Generic.IEnumerable<Employee> empIEnumerable = new List<Employee>
            {   new Employee { ID = 1001, Name="Mahsa"},
                new Employee { ID = 1002, Name = "Hassankashi" },
                new Employee { ID = 1003, Name = "CosmicVerse" },
                new Employee { ID = 1004, Name = "Technical" }
            };
    
    
            this.GridViewIEnumerable.DataSource = empIEnumerable;
            this.GridViewIEnumerable.DataBind();
    
            System.Text.StringBuilder str = new System.Text.StringBuilder();
    
            foreach (Employee item in empIEnumerable)
            {
                str.Append(" , " + item.ID +"-"+item.Name);
            }
    
            this.lblIEnumerable.Text = str.ToString();

## IQueryable ##

![9.jpg][]

Follow "Entity Framework DatabaseFirst" from this article for making DBContext

![minus.gif][]  Collapse  |  [Copy Code][]

DataAccessEntities ctx = new DataAccessEntities();
            var ctx = new DataAccessEntities();

[Data Access][IList vs IEnumerable vs IQueryable vs ICollection vs IDictionary]

![minus.gif][]  Collapse  |  [Copy Code][]

//Difference between IQueryable and IEnumerable
    
            //You can instantiate IEnumerable from List
    
            IEnumerable<Employee> queryIEnumerable = new List<Employee>() ;
    
    
            //Bring  ALL records from server --> to client then filter collection 
            queryIEnumerable = (from m in ctx.Employees
                         where m.ID == 1
                         select m).ToList();
    
    
    
    
            //You can not instantiate IQueryable
    
            IQueryable<Employee> queryIQueryable=null;
    
            //Bring just ONE record from server --> to client 
            queryIQueryable = (from m in ctx.Employees
                         where m.ID == 1
                         select m);
    
    
            this.GridViewIQueryable.DataSource = queryIQueryable.ToList();
            this.GridViewIQueryable.DataBind();

## ICollection ##

![minus.gif][]  Collapse  |  [Copy Code][]

//IList {indexer and Modify} vs ICollection {randomly and Modify}         
            //Collection can not be instantiate from ICollection , so it should be instantiate from List
            System.Collections.Generic.ICollection<string> strICollection = new List<string>();
            strICollection.Add("Mahsa");
            strICollection.Add("Hassankashi");
            //**Countable int ICollectionCount=strICollection.Count; this.ListBoxICollection.DataSource = strICollection; this.ListBoxICollection.DataBind(); System.Text.StringBuilder str = new System.Text.StringBuilder(); foreach (var item in strICollection) { str.Append(" , " + item); } this.lblICollection.Text = str.ToString(); //***IList System.Collections.Generic.IList<Employee> objIList = new List<Employee>(); objIList = (from m in ctx.Employees select m).ToList(); Employee obj = objIList.Where(i => i.Name == "Sara").FirstOrDefault(); int indexofSara= objIList.IndexOf(obj); int cIList = objIList.Count; //***ICollection System.Collections.Generic.ICollection<Employee> objICollection = new List<Employee>(); objICollection = (from m in ctx.Employees select m).ToList(); Employee objIC = objICollection.Where(i => i.Name == "Sara").FirstOrDefault(); //You can not get index of object , if you clear comment from below code appears error // int indexofSaraICollection = objIC.IndexOf(objIC); int cICollection = objICollection.Count;

## Dictionary ##

![minus.gif][]  Collapse  |  [Copy Code][]

//Dictionary can instantiate from Dictionary , Dictionary is similar to Hashtable,         //Dictionary is GENERIC but Hashtable is NON GENERIC         //Such Hashtable you can find object by its key 
            System.Collections.Generic.Dictionary<int, string=""> objDictionary = new Dictionary<int, string="">();
    
            objDictionary.Add(1001, "Mahsa");
            objDictionary.Add(1002, "Hassankashi");
            objDictionary.Add(1003, "Cosmicverse");
    
            string str = objDictionary[1002];
    
            this.ListBoxDictionary.DataSource = objDictionary;
            this.ListBoxDictionary.DataBind();</int,></int,>

MVC Tutorial: [http://technical.cosmicverse.info/Article/Index/3][http_technical.cosmicverse.info_Article_Index_3]

Data Access Layer Tutorial: [http://technical.cosmicverse.info/Article/Index/4][IList vs IEnumerable vs IQueryable vs ICollection vs IDictionary]

### References ###

[http://www.codeproject.com/Articles/732425/IEnumerable-Vs-IQueryable][http_www.codeproject.com_Articles_732425_IEnumerable-Vs-IQueryable]

[http://www.dotnet-tricks.com/Tutorial/linq/I8SY160612-IEnumerable-VS-IQueryable.html][http_www.dotnet-tricks.com_Tutorial_linq_I8SY160612-IEnumerable-VS-IQueryable.html]

[http://www.claudiobernasconi.ch/2013/07/22/when-to-use-ienumerable-icollection-ilist-and-list][http_www.claudiobernasconi.ch_2013_07_22_when-to-use-ienumerable-icollection-ilist-and-list]

[http_www.codeproject.com_Articles_832189_List-vs-IEnumerable-vs-IQueryable-vs-ICollection-v]: http://www.codeproject.com/Articles/832189/List-vs-IEnumerable-vs-IQueryable-vs-ICollection-v
[IList vs IEnumerable vs IQueryable vs ICollection vs IDictionary]: http://technical.cosmicverse.info/Article/Index/4
[IList vs IEnumerable vs IQueryable vs ICollection vs IDictionary - 494.3 KB]: http://www.codeproject.com/KB/cs/832189/Collection.zip
[CompleteCollectionComparison.jpg]: /images/20220616/9ae08ca081a443f58d94c205a9705d3a.png
[Container]: http://lib.csdn.net/base/docker
[1.jpg]: /images/20220616/0be9a14ef5714a65bc8fa349add34012.png
[2.jpg]: /images/20220616/f16698ea71b6407781f6c507c71fc278.png
[minus.gif]: /images/20220616/e2840dc0eda849bf8994f131b739afd7.png
[Copy Code]: http://www.codeproject.com/Articles/832189/List-vs-IEnumerable-vs-IQueryable-vs-ICollection-v#
[3.jpg]: /images/20220616/f93f433ca5fa43b388168de1bea6fe0b.png
[4.jpg]: /images/20220616/c95d2cd3b8e44a0ab9deffcf557d086c.png
[5.jpg]: /images/20220616/a04c4aa0422944a78dce8acf6f11335a.png
[6.jpg]: /images/20220616/767d3570812e4623b4c54b6c5db2470b.png
[7.jpg]: /images/20220616/cc6c6f4ec7904223b00d29e2d7fe54d2.png
[8.jpg]: /images/20220616/f495a6b10e784dbb8508654e47d77414.png
[9.jpg]: /images/20220616/7d5cf53b174941b5a9560580c41735e9.png
[http_technical.cosmicverse.info_Article_Index_3]: http://technical.cosmicverse.info/Article/Index/3
[http_www.codeproject.com_Articles_732425_IEnumerable-Vs-IQueryable]: http://www.codeproject.com/Articles/732425/IEnumerable-Vs-IQueryable
[http_www.dotnet-tricks.com_Tutorial_linq_I8SY160612-IEnumerable-VS-IQueryable.html]: http://www.dotnet-tricks.com/Tutorial/linq/I8SY160612-IEnumerable-VS-IQueryable.html
[http_www.claudiobernasconi.ch_2013_07_22_when-to-use-ienumerable-icollection-ilist-and-list]: http://www.claudiobernasconi.ch/2013/07/22/when-to-use-ienumerable-icollection-ilist-and-list

发表评论取消回复

表情：

评论列表（有 0 条评论，290人围观）

还没有评论，来说两句吧...

相关阅读

相关 Java List 对比：ArrayList vs. LinkedList vs. Vector

Java List 对比：ArrayList vs. LinkedList vs. Vector 本文译自：[ArrayList vs. LinkedList vs. V

悠悠/ 2024年03月27日 09:25/ 0 赞/ 84 阅读

相关模型相关术语：Model vs DTO vs Entity vs Value Object vs Pojo vs Bean

此存储库的目标是明确一些术语的含义，这些术语在开发社区中造成了很多混乱。我想提一下，这个澄清将从Java开发人员的角度进行。型模型 DTO 今天称为数据传输对象

青旅半醒/ 2023年09月26日 09:41/ 0 赞/ 132 阅读

相关 &VS&&

&—逻辑与 | —逻辑或！—逻辑非 && —短路与 || —短路或 ^ —逻辑异或 ![在这里插入图片描述][watermark_type_ZmFuZ3poZW

爱被打了一巴掌/ 2022年09月03日 12:23/ 0 赞/ 182 阅读

相关 List vs IEnumerable vs IQueryable vs ICollection vs IDictionary

原文：[http://www.codeproject.com/Articles/832189/List-vs-IEnumerable-vs-IQueryable-vs-ICol

桃扇骨/ 2022年08月13日 12:45/ 0 赞/ 270 阅读

相关 MVC vs. MVP vs. MVVM

1 简介　　英文原文： [MVC vs. MVP vs. MVVM ][MVC vs._MVP vs._MVVM] 　　三者的目的都是分离关注，使得UI更容易变换（从

朱雀/ 2022年07月27日 13:35/ 0 赞/ 223 阅读

相关 Benchmark: PHP vs. Python vs. Perl vs. Ruby

[Benchmark: PHP vs. Python vs. Perl vs. Ruby][Benchmark_ PHP vs. Python vs. Perl vs. Ru

水深无声/ 2022年06月18日 06:38/ 0 赞/ 261 阅读

相关 Memcache VS Memcached VS MemcacheDB

Memcache VS Memcached VS MemcacheDB 1、简单讲Memcache和Memcached都讲的是同一个开源项目http

心已赠人/ 2022年06月16日 20:42/ 0 赞/ 220 阅读

相关 List vs IEnumerable vs IQueryable vs ICollection vs IDictionary

原文：[http://www.codeproject.com/Articles/832189/List-vs-IEnumerable-vs-IQueryable-vs-ICol

迷南。/ 2022年06月16日 02:36/ 0 赞/ 291 阅读

相关 HashSet vs. TreeSet vs. LinkedHashSet

Set接口定义集合中没有重复元素，Java中有3种常用的Set实现：HashSet，TreeSet和LinkedHashSet。什么时候使用应该使用哪个需要根据实际情况来确认，

àì夳堔傛蜴生んèń/ 2022年05月15日 03:13/ 0 赞/ 292 阅读

相关 OLTP VS OLAP VS HTAP

[https://blog.bcmeng.com/post/oltp-olap-htap.html][https_blog.bcmeng.com_post_oltp-olap-

﹏ヽ暗。殇╰゛Y/ 2022年02月23日 01:04/ 0 赞/ 273 阅读